Is WiFi Calling All It’s Cracked Up to Be?

WiFi Calling

All eyes were on Google last week as it rolled out Pixel and Pixel XL, two new in-house devices launched in partnership with Verizon. And as CNET reports, we now have word that the Pixel can also be used with Google’s Project Fi—which begs the question: Is WiFi calling actually worth it?

At first glance, the answer appears to be yes; but closer inspection reveals some potential pitfalls.

Programs like Project Fi work in concert with major carriers. The idea (and marketing push)  is to offer cheaper wireless service by toggling calls between WiFi and cellular coverage from big-player networks. In other words, automatically connecting to WiFi hotspots could possibly translate to lower service costs. Project Fi is already in action, with Comcast slated to launch its own program next year.

In theory, it sounds like a good idea, but there are definitely a few caveats. For starters, the pricing model bundles in talk and text together, which is problematic for a number of reasons. Today’s mobile users are pivoting more and more from voice to text. According to a 2015 report from Informate, Americans send and receive five times as many daily texts as phone calls.

One Glove Does Not Fit All (and Neither Does WiFi Calling)

This is precisely why US Mobile customers can create their own customized plans—no two users are alike; some only need 100 minutes of talk, while others need 5,000. The point here is that taking a one-size-fits-all approach to mobile usage often translates to customers paying for more than they need.

With Project Fi, for instance, talk and text are a hand-in-hand deal. The starting point for their monthly plans is $20, which gets you unlimited calls and texting. This means that opting out of unlimited talk isn’t an option. That isn’t unlike a cable company bundling cable and Internet along with home phone service, even though most Americans have no need for a landline phone.

Data usage is another likely downside. Project Fi charges users $10 for every gigabyte of data they use. The truth is that most users will blow through one gigabyte relatively quickly. Forbes writer Shelby Carpenter calls it Project Fi’s Achilles heel, adding that unlimited talk and text plus 4GB of data will run you $60 per month. Other programs offer slightly cheaper prices, but nothing too substantial.

Data aside, what we really want to get into here is voice quality, which can be questionable when your calls are offset from cellular to WiFi. Some who have tried it say that call quality can be choppy or distorted. Others have reported issues with lag time when making WiFi calls. What’s more, if you’re talking on the go, call quality may become compromised if you go out of range of the WiFi network.

The kinks of WiFi calling show no signs of being ironed out anytime soon, which means that US Mobile will continue offering affordable prepaid plans. As the old saying goes, “If it ain’t broke, don’t fix it.”


Image Source: blog.kaspersky.es

6 thoughts on “Is WiFi Calling All It’s Cracked Up to Be?”

  1. Molly_WI says:

    I can think of a great reason for wifi calling; poor cell service at home. Tmobile works great everywhere around me except, it seems, at my house. Good thing I still have an internet “land line”.

    1. soulife says:

      I completely agree.. While wifi calling may be useless to some, it is not only useful to others but it’s also pivotal.. Without wifi calling, i wouldn’t have service at home or work.. It’s kinda foolish to bash a feature that expands service and enhances end user experience

  2. soulife says:

    Google Voice allows calls to be handled over wifi using their hangouts app. I’ve been using google voice since 2007, so everyone has my GV number and has never actually had my real cell number, I’m on wifi at home, and wifi at work, which is where the majority of my talk time takes place, not only that but the only carrier in my area that gives me reliable signal at home and work is AT&T, so wifi calling is a must for me if i want service outside of AT&T.

    Also, it is GV’s wifi calling that allows me to use MVNOs like US Mobile, because i can get by with only a 100 minute, 0 text, 3gb data (it was 4gb but 4gb seems to have been downed to 3 since my last bill!? wtf not fair) plan for less than $30.. Otherwise, i would be stuck using a carrier that offers wifi calling. But also, once you start pushing that +$30 range, US Mobile starts becoming less of the better option, ie: for $35 i could for example have unlimited talk/txt/5gb data through Boost Mobile, etc..

    I just wish that US Mobile could allow me to use Androids built in Wifi calling option so i didn’t have to be tethered to using the Hangouts app..

    1. Boston02116 says:

      I use Google Voice. Sometimes call quality is terrible and people want to hang up on me. Not sure why they can’t make it better? Why does a regular cell call work so well but everything over Wifi sucks? Must be the cell system is designed for low latency and packet priority etc

      1. soulife says:

        Several factors can lead to a crappy GV call.. Obviously, the strength of your data connection (ie: wifi signal for example), but also the phones cpu and ram influence call quality as well..

        So if for example you have a mid to low end phone that is downloading play store updates in the background, your GV call quality will most likely be effected.. The same can be true for high end phones as well if you just happen to be pushing the limits of its hardware at the time of your GV call (updating apps with 20 chrome tabs open while streaming a movie to chromecast with the calculator open trying to divide pie by 0, etc)
        Afterall, GV is just a normal app placing a call on your phone VS. the dedicated hardware and system integrated software handling your cellular calls..

        I rarely have GV quality issues on decently spec’ed phones. But it happens sometimes. Back when i was between phones i bought a cheap $40 phone just to hold me over and 90% of my calls were crap. Now 98% of my calls are fine..

  3. Clarid Mutchler says:

    Pretty sassy way of defending an obvious lack of a considerably beneficial feature. I mean, sassy is good and all, but carriers that offer wifi calling/texting definitely score more points for usability over sass :3

    I came across this blog post looking specifically for carriers that do offer wifi calling since I live in such a remote area that signal is patchy unless I’m “goin’ to the big city” haha. I had Project Fi for nearly two years and never had quality issues with any of the Nexus phones or any of the other countless phones I put my SIM card into. As long as I had access to hangouts, I could text and call without issue (both a benefit and a curse when you get sick of hangout’s ish).

    So I’m currently shopping for carriers with affordable plans and wifi calling for when I’m home (most of the time). Not to be a jerk, but in all honesty it appears as if my best bet is returning to Project Fi and their premium price for The Basics.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *